Forensic Errors Cloud Takeoff Murder Case

Photo Courtesy HPD

The trial of Patrick Clark, the suspect accused of fatally shooting Migos rapper Takeoff, faces potential complications following revelations of forensic mishandling by a former Houston Forensic Science Center analyst, Rochelle Austen, who has now been terminated.

Documents obtained by Houston media outlet ABC13 highlight Austen's errors. These errors include switching DNA samples and violating chain of custody procedures, prompting scrutiny over their impact on Clark's case.

Takeoff, whose real name was Kirshnik Khari Ball, was killed outside a Houston bowling alley on November 1, 2022, sending shockwaves throughout the music industry. A pivotal member of the Grammy-nominated group Migos, Takeoff was known for his laidback demeanor and intricate flow that helped propel the group's success and influence countless artists.

Houston Forensic analyst Rochelle Austin fired after Mishandling DNA evidence in many cases. She is the analyst for Takeoff’s murder case against Patrick Clark, and was supposed to serve as a witness. They’re not aware if she mishandled his case as of now. It is being looked…

— Good Job, O (@InternationalO) April 18, 2024

"Since she did mess up, they can never put her on the stand again, and the defense attorney would vigorously cross-examine her," said defense attorney Murray Newman, highlighting the potential impact of the revelations on the trial.

While details surrounding the shooting remain murky, prosecutors allege Clark's involvement in a dice game altercation that escalated to gunfire. Security footage reportedly captured Clark firing a weapon, with a nearby camera providing crucial evidence. His fingerprints were also found on a wine bottle left at the scene. Clark maintains his innocence.

On this day, Takeoff, one third of the rap group Migos, was shot and killed outside of a bowling alley in Houston, Texas.

Police were able to use surveillance footage, cell phone videos, and fingerprints from a wine bottle to identify the suspect as 33-year-old Patrick Clark of… pic.twitter.com/iiB2FqWers

— Investigation Discovery (@DiscoveryID) November 1, 2023

The Harris County District Attorney's Office, proactively addressing potential issues, filed 392 Brady Notices, including one in Clark's case, notifying defense attorneys of the evidence mishandling.

Clark's attorney, Letitia Quinones, expressed concern, indicating plans to investigate how the errors might affect the defense. "This is something of concern for us, and we will be investigating it to see exactly how it affects our client's case," Quinones said.

Surveillance footage allegedly depicts Clark holding a gun and leaving behind a wine bottle, with his fingerprints linking him to the scene. However, FOX 26 Houston's Legal Analyst, Chris Tritico, emphasized the importance of maintaining a chain of custody in forensic science, suggesting that compromised evidence could weaken the prosecution's case.

Takeoff murder suspect Patrick Clark was able to post the $1 million bond and was released from jail

🔗:https://t.co/Gwa3Fa0K29 pic.twitter.com/dRf7UTNDZF

— Glock Topickz (@Glock_Topickz) January 5, 2023

Clark, who posted a $1 million bond in January 2023, anticipates returning to court on May 29. The revelations of forensic errors add a layer of complexity to the case, prompting heightened scrutiny.

Timeline:
Nov. 1, 2022: Takeoff is fatally shot.
Dec. 2022: Patrick Clark is arrested and charged with murder.
May. 2023: Grand jury indicts Clark on murder charges.
Dec. 2023: Clark is released on bond with house arrest restrictions.
March 2024: Forensic analyst Rochelle Austen is terminated, and her mishandling of evidence, including a chain of custody mix-up in Clark's case, is revealed.
April 2024: Clark's house arrest restrictions are lifted.